Korean IP service for foreign counsel

Design Invalidation and Design Similarity in Korea

SODAM assists with Korean design invalidation, design similarity opinions, and dispute analysis by reviewing overall visual impression, material design features, product shape, prior designs, and evidence.

Korean Design Invalidation and Similarity: Key Points

Grounds for Invalidating a Korean Design

An interested party or an examiner may file an invalidation trial against a registered design with the Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (Design Protection Act, Article 121(1)). The central grounds are lack of novelty, where the design is identical or similar to a design that was publicly known, publicly worked, or published before filing, and lack of creativity, where a person of ordinary skill could easily have created it from such designs or from widely known shapes, patterns, or colors (Article 33(1) and (2)). A trial may be filed even after the design right has lapsed (Article 121(2)). The applicant's own disclosure within 12 months before filing may be disregarded as prior art if the statutory requirements are met (Article 36(1)).

How Similarity Is Assessed

Korean practice compares designs as a whole, focusing on the overall aesthetic impression on an ordinary observer rather than on isolated details. Features that are functional, common in the product category, or already found in earlier designs tend to carry less weight, while the parts that draw the observer's attention carry more. The protected scope of a registered design is determined by the application, the drawings, photographs or specimens, and the design description (Article 93), so the registration documents, not the right holder's commercial product, are the starting point. Side-by-side comparison tables using the registered drawings and photographs of the actual product are central to the analysis.

Partially Examined Designs and Registration Opposition

For certain product categories, Korea registers designs after a partial examination that does not include a full search of earlier designs. Such registrations can be challenged through a registration opposition: anyone may file from registration until three months after publication of the registration, and a party that has received a notice of infringement may file within three months of that notice, but no later than one year after publication (Design Protection Act, Article 68(1)). Oppositions are decided by a panel of three MOIP examiners (Article 70(1)), and an invalidation trial remains available separately. Scope confirmation trials are also available for designs (Article 122).

Key Issues We Review

  • Overall visual impression and material design features.
  • Novelty, creativity, and comparison with prior designs.
  • Product category, drawings, photos, and evidence quality.
  • Coordination with customs, marketplace, warning-letter, or litigation strategy where relevant.

Documents and Information to Send

  • Registered design drawings, bibliographic information, and prosecution materials if available.
  • Product photos, CAD drawings, samples, catalogues, and online product pages.
  • Prior design references and comparative materials.
  • Foreign opinions or dispute materials if strategically relevant.
  • A signed power of attorney in favor of SODAM.

Typical Stages and Deadlines

  1. Record review. Collect the registered drawings, the product at issue, and dated earlier designs such as catalogues, online listings, and prior registrations.
  2. Filing. Choose between a registration opposition, where still within the period, and an invalidation trial, or file a scope confirmation petition for the product at issue.
  3. Exchange. The right holder answers, and the parties exchange comparison tables and evidence.
  4. Decision and appeal. A Board decision may be challenged before the Patent Court of Korea within 30 days of service (Article 166(3)).

How SODAM Assists Foreign Counsel

  • Prepare visual comparison tables and issue maps.
  • Assess invalidation and similarity arguments under Korean design practice.
  • Draft Korean submissions or opinions based on the available record.
  • Provide English reporting for foreign counsel and business teams.

Related Korean IP Services

FAQ

Is design similarity decided by one feature?
Usually, the overall visual impression and the role of material features should be reviewed rather than relying on one isolated feature.
Can prior designs affect both invalidity and scope?
Yes. Prior designs can be important for invalidation, similarity, and scope analysis depending on the record.
What evidence is useful for design comparison?
Clear drawings, product photos, samples, catalogues, and prior design materials are often useful, subject to case-specific review.

Contact

Discuss a Korean IP Matter

Please send the relevant documents, procedural status, and the requested Korean IP work. SODAM will review the matter and respond with the appropriate next step.

Reviewed by Injae Yeo, Korean patent attorney | Published by SODAM IP