Korean IP service for foreign counsel
Patent Invalidation Trial before the Korean IP Trial Board
SODAM assists foreign associates and global clients with Korean patent invalidation trials before the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board, including claim-by-claim validity analysis, prior art mapping, evidence review, and Korean trial submissions.
Korean Patent Invalidation Trials: Key Points
Who May File and When
An invalidation trial before the Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board may be filed by an interested party or by an examiner (Patent Act, Article 133(1)). In practice, the petitioner is usually a company that has received a warning letter, has been sued for infringement, or makes or plans to make a product close to the claims. The petition may be directed at individual claims, and it may be filed even after the patent has expired (Article 133(2)). Separately, anyone may file a patent cancellation request, on limited grounds based on prior publications and earlier applications, from registration until six months after publication of the registration (Article 132-2). The two routes differ in standing, grounds, and procedure, so the choice should be made at the outset.
Grounds and the Legal Standard
The grounds for invalidation are listed in Article 133(1). Those most often argued are lack of novelty or inventive step (Article 29), lack of enablement (Article 42(3)(i)), lack of claim support or clarity (Article 42(4)), and amendments that went beyond the original disclosure (Article 47(2)). Inventive step is assessed from the standpoint of a person of ordinary skill in the art before the filing date, comparing each claim, properly construed, with the cited references. Because the Board decides claim by claim, each ground should be tied to specific claim elements and to specific passages of the evidence. When a decision invalidating the patent becomes final, the patent is in principle deemed never to have existed (Article 133(3)).
The Patentee's Response: Correction Requests
The patentee may answer not only with arguments but also with a request to correct the specification or drawings within the periods the Board designates, principally the period for filing its answer (Article 133-2(1)). A correction is limited to narrowing the claims, correcting clerical errors, or clarifying unclear descriptions, and it may not substantially enlarge or change the claims (Article 136, applied through Article 133-2(4)). For the petitioner, a correction can move the target during the proceeding, so the evidence plan should anticipate likely fallback claims. For the patentee, a timely correction can preserve commercially important claims, but every narrowing also affects later infringement arguments. SODAM reviews both effects before a correction is filed.
Key Issues We Review
- Claim construction and element-by-element prior art comparison.
- Selection and organization of invalidation grounds and supporting evidence.
- Consistency between Korean IP Trial Board arguments and related infringement or foreign proceedings.
- Technical explanation suited to the Board's administrative patent judges.
Documents and Information to Send
- Korean patent publication or registration information, claims, specification, and drawings.
- Prior art references, translations, search reports, or foreign invalidity contentions if available.
- Product or process materials relevant to the commercial dispute.
- Foreign prosecution, opposition, invalidation, or litigation history where strategically relevant.
- A signed power of attorney in favor of SODAM. A party with no domicile or place of business in Korea must act through a Korean patent administrator (Patent Act, Article 5).
Typical Stages and Deadlines
- Petition. The petitioner files a petition identifying the challenged claims, the grounds, and the evidence. The Board serves a copy on the patentee.
- Answer and correction. The patentee files an answer within the designated period and may request correction of the claims.
- Further briefs and hearing. The parties exchange rebuttal briefs, and the Board may hold an oral hearing, which is often used to clarify technical points.
- Decision and appeal. The Board issues a written decision claim by claim. A dissatisfied party may file an action with the Patent Court of Korea within 30 days of service of the decision (Article 186(3)).
How SODAM Assists Foreign Counsel
- Prepare validity charts and technical issue lists for foreign counsel review.
- Develop Korean invalidation arguments based on the record and available evidence.
- Draft and file Korean trial submissions through qualified Korean representatives.
- Provide English reporting on procedural status, risk points, and next-step options.
Related Korean IP Services
FAQ
- Can a foreign company file a Korean patent invalidation trial?
- Yes. A foreign company may challenge the validity of a Korean patent through a qualified Korean representative, subject to the applicable procedural requirements.
- Is prior art analysis enough for invalidation?
- Prior art analysis is often central, but claim interpretation, evidentiary support, technical explanation, and procedural posture should also be reviewed.
- Can invalidation strategy be coordinated with litigation?
- Yes. Invalidation arguments should be coordinated with enforcement, non-infringement, settlement, and foreign proceedings where those issues are relevant.
Contact
Discuss a Korean IP Matter
Please send the relevant documents, procedural status, and the requested Korean IP work. SODAM will review the matter and respond with the appropriate next step.