Korean IP service for foreign counsel
Scope Confirmation Trial in Korea
SODAM supports Korean scope confirmation trials by defining the target product or process, preparing technical comparison charts, and developing arguments on whether the target falls within the scope of a Korean IP right.
Korean Scope Confirmation Trials: Key Points
What the Trial Decides
A scope confirmation trial asks the Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board one question: does a specifically described product or process (the subject of confirmation) fall within the protected scope of a registered right? The procedure is available for patents (Patent Act, Article 135), trademarks (Trademark Act, Article 121), and designs (Design Protection Act, Article 122). The Board compares the subject with the claims, the registered mark, or the registered design. It does not award damages or order an injunction. The decision is therefore a technical and legal determination that parties use alongside infringement litigation, marketplace disputes, and settlement discussions, rather than a substitute for enforcement in court.
Positive and Negative Petitions
There are two forms. In a positive petition, the patentee or an exclusive licensee asks the Board to confirm that another party's product falls within the scope of the patent (Patent Act, Article 135(1)). In a negative petition, an interested party, typically a company that has received a warning letter, asks the Board to confirm that its own product falls outside the scope (Article 135(2)). Where the patent has two or more claims, the petition may be filed claim by claim (Article 135(3)). A negative petition can be filed before any lawsuit, which lets the recipient of a warning letter frame the comparison on the basis of its own product and evidence.
Defining the Subject of Confirmation
The petition must describe the product or process specifically enough to allow an element-by-element comparison with the claims, usually through a written description and drawings. In a positive petition, the description must also match what the respondent actually makes or uses; a mismatch can lead to dismissal without a ruling on the merits. Typical defenses include a missing claim element, a different structure or mode of operation, and the argument that the subject consists of prior art or could easily have been derived from it by a person skilled in the art (often called the free-to-practice defense). The validity of the patent itself is generally addressed in a separate invalidation trial, which is why the two proceedings are often run in parallel.
Key Issues We Review
- Precise definition of the target product, process, or embodiment.
- Claim construction and technical feature comparison.
- Relationship with infringement litigation, invalidation trials, and commercial negotiation.
- Evidence needed to support the defined comparison target.
Documents and Information to Send
- Korean patent, utility model, design, or trademark materials relevant to the right at issue.
- Target product drawings, manuals, photos, samples, process descriptions, or technical documents.
- Existing claim charts, foreign counsel analysis, or dispute correspondence.
- Known litigation, warning letter, or licensing context if relevant.
- A signed power of attorney in favor of SODAM.
Typical Stages and Deadlines
- Preparation. Define the subject of confirmation and prepare the claim comparison chart, together with evidence of the product as actually made, sold, or used.
- Petition and answer. The Board serves the petition. The respondent answers and may dispute the description of the subject or raise the free-to-practice defense.
- Briefs and hearing. The parties exchange briefs, and an oral hearing may be held on technical points.
- Decision and appeal. The Board decides whether the subject falls within the scope. A dissatisfied party may file an action with the Patent Court of Korea within 30 days of service of the decision (Patent Act, Article 186(3)).
How SODAM Assists Foreign Counsel
- Define the comparison target in a procedurally usable manner.
- Prepare element-by-element claim or design comparison charts.
- Develop Korean trial arguments and supporting evidence strategy.
- Coordinate English reporting with related dispute objectives.
Related Korean IP Services
FAQ
- Is a scope confirmation trial the same as infringement litigation?
- No. It is a separate Korean procedure focused on whether a defined target falls within the scope of a right, although it may be strategically related to infringement disputes.
- Why is target definition important?
- The trial comparison depends on the defined product, process, or embodiment. An imprecise target can weaken the usefulness of the proceeding.
- Can the proceeding support settlement discussions?
- In appropriate cases, a structured Korean scope position may assist risk evaluation and negotiation strategy.
Contact
Discuss a Korean IP Matter
Please send the relevant documents, procedural status, and the requested Korean IP work. SODAM will review the matter and respond with the appropriate next step.